article analysis grading rubric an essential skill whether you enter t
Search for question
Question
ARTICLE ANALYSIS GRADING RUBRIC
An essential skill, whether you enter the field of Biochemistry or a related discipline, is to be able
to summarize and evaluate empirical research. Empirical research refers to research articles that
present novel research findings (as opposed to providing an opinion or review). These readings
and your textbook provide an overview of the breadth of the research on Biochemistry.
As a first step towards completing a literature review for this project, you will need to: find a
research article related to Biochemistry class subject what you are learning in this class, read and
summarize the introduction, methods, results, and conclusions, and provide a critical analysis of
the article and its relation to your topic.
STEP#1: Finding an article
You must find an EMPIRICAL (research) article related to Class of interest to the
Biochemistry subject. Some of your search should be following the example but no need to be
similar, you can look for any journal with full article available:
https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C10&as_vis=1&q=glycolysis+an
d+cancer+full+article&btnG=
• https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C10&as_vis=1&q=citric+acid+c
ycle+research+article+full+article&btnG=
• https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=biochemistry&filter=simsearch2.ffrft&filter=years
.2018-2024&sort=date&sort_order=asc&format=abstract
STEP#2: Reading your article
Read the article in full and understand the scientific language. You may corelate you understanding
with Subject, any additional reading is recommended to understand the scientific paper.
STEP#3: Writing your summary and analysis.
Your summary and analysis should not exceed 3 pages, double spaced, in 12pt. Times New
Roman font. Your paper should include your full first and last name, Your paper should then
include the following information:
Summary: What theoretical idea(s) or research questions inspired the study? What
methods were used to investigate the topic? What were the most notable results? What
implications do the results have for real life and/or for future research?
• Analysis: How do these findings relate to your Biochemistry's topic? How does this
research help to answer your question? What were the main strengths of the article? What
did you thinkthe authors did especially well in describing or analyzing their results?
What interpretations did the authors make that you think are in error, unjustified, or over-
stated?What lingering questions do you have?
Include the full reference for the paper you are analyzing at the end. Youdo not need any
additional citations for the assignment and this reference is not included in your page
requirements.
Submit your final analysis in Word or PDF online via Dropbox. The grading rubric for this
assignment is below. Points
15
GRADING RUBRIC FOR ARTICLE ANALYSIS
Description
Page 1
Summary
Page 2
Analysis
Format
Mechanics
Unacceptable
(Below standards)
The student does not clearly summarize the
main points of the article (i.e., the main
research question, methods, results, and
implications) and/or includes inaccurate
information.
The student does not clearly move beyond a
summary of the article to provide an
analysis. No correlation with the
Biochemistry class subject. No new ideas
are contributed beyond what is in the article
itself, or the analysis is overly confusing.
Paper does not follow all formatting
guidelines outlined in the syllabus, and
either fails to cite the article, or cites in
inaccurately.
Grammatical, punctuation, and spelling
errors significantly detract from reading the
paper. Basic sentence structure often
includes
poor structure (e.g., run-on
sentences).
Acceptable
(Meets minimum standards)
Most of the article is summarized, but the
student may not clearly cover all aspects (i.e.,
the main research question, methods, results,
and implications).
The student provides an analysis of the article
and corelates to the Biochemistry class
subject. The ideas presented are mostly
novel, going beyond what is in the article
itself.
Paper is 2 pages long, follows all formatting
guidelines outlined in the syllabus, and
accurately cites the article in APA format at
the end.
There may be a few grammatical, punctuation,
and/or spelling errors, but overall they do not
detract too much from reading the paper.
Basic sentence structure is good (e.g., avoids
run-on sentences, sentence structure is solid).
Good
(Exceeds minimum standards)
The summary clearly outlines the main
research question, methods, results, and
implications in the student's own words.
The student provides an insightful analysis
of the article and perfectly corelates with
the Biochemistry class subject. The
student articulates novel ideas that clearly
go beyond what is in the article itself. The
analysis is clear and rational.
Paper is 2 pages long, follows all formatting
guidelines outlined in the syllabus, and
accurately cites the article in APA format at
the end.
Grammatical, punctuation, and spelling
errors are RARE and do not detract from
reading the paper. Basic sentence structure
is good (e.g., avoids run-on sentences,
sentence structure is solid).
Total Possible Points
20
20
5
10
50