a sketch planning exercise to estimate demand for a commuter bus servi
Search for question
Question
A Sketch Planning exercise to estimate demand for a commuter bus
service.
Background
What is Sketch Planning? It is a high-level approach to develop transportation planning estimates.
Sketch-Planning Tools. Sketch-planning methodologies and tools produce general order-of-magnitude
estimates of travel demand and traffic operations in response to transportation improvements. They
allow for the evaluation of specific projects or alternatives without conducting an in-depth engineering
analysis. Sketch-planning tools perform some or all of the functions of other analytical tools using
simplified techniques and highly aggregate data.
-Meyer, Michael D.. Transportation Planning Handbook, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2016.
ProQuest Ebook Central,
While something like a travel demand model relies on estimating trips, distributing and assigning to a
network, Sketch Planning may rely on a set of reasonable estimates based on realistic assumptions. For
example, if you were to try and estimate the demand for a bus service between two communities, you
might start by looking at data you have access to, such as Journey to Work data that shows how many
people are commuting. You may try and find estimates of modal split, like what percentage of people
use a bus when it is available, or you could even use a binary logit model like out of NCHRP 365 or 716
based on travel times (I can provide both references). You may also do a sensitivity analysis that shows
a range of realistic values if such numbers are not available.
Scope
Using the Statistics Canada Journey to Work Data
(https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/cv.action?pid=9810045901), you will need to review
commuting patterns for a city (choose from the list in Table 1 below) and choose one set of
origin/destination pairs among the top 10 origin/destination pairs that you think has potential for a
commuter bus service where one does not exist. Note any communities that may already served by
regional transit service (e.g. Moncton, Dieppe, Riverview is the only one in NB) or commuter bus
services (e.g. COMEX in Saint John) and choose a different community not served by these services.
This will be formatted as a technical lab report, including appropriate introduction, background,
,methodology, analysis, conclusion and recommendation.
1. For your city, identify the top 10 communities that have your city as the destination and the top
10 communities where your city is the origin (do not include the city itself)
a. Choose one origin/destination pair (the city and commuter census subdivision) to
evaluate as a potential commuter bus service route and justify that choice. It does NOT
have to be the busiest route, I would like you to pick one that is relevant or interesting
to you.
2. Create a demographic and socio-economic profile of study area, including the city commuter
census subdivision.
a. Population in 2021, 2016 and population change (if possible) b. Population Density
C.
Median Age
3. Include a map that clearly identifies the communities. You should also describe any other
community characteristics that may influence transportation use:
d. Geographic characteristics
e.
Mode choice (Statistics Canada Journey to Work Commuter profiles, CHASS)
i. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/cv.action?pid=9810046201
f. Existing services in the area, existing transportation & road connections.
g. Travel distances between each community.
4. Prepare an analysis of the commuting data, including any additional information, assumptions,
equations, etc, that you may draw from the ITE Planning Handbook, NCHRP 716, and any other
technical resource you might find to estimate potential ridership and present your estimates.
Identify any limitations or caveats regarding your estimates.
Conclusions and Recommendations
Prepare a set of conclusions and recommendations for next steps based on your analysis, including
whether a commuter bus service may make sense or whether there may be other options to
consider. Report of 750-1000 words.
This will be evaluated according to the lab rubric, with top marks going to innovative and insightful
approaches that seek to meaningfully answer the question.
Other instructions
1.
I will not answer any questions about how to do the test/report or how to work the Statistics
Canada website- you are on your own to figure out how to interpret the requirements of this
exercise. State any assumptions you need to make.
Table 1: Destination Cities
Destination Cities
Moncton (City) 1307022 and Moncton CMA
Dieppe (City & Moncton CMA)
Saint John (City & CMA)
Edmundston (City & CA)
Fredericton (City & CA)
Miramichi (City & CA)
Campbellton (City & CA)
Bathurst (City & CA)/n Instructions
Need report in 1000 words excluding the resources
the format of the report is Introduction, Background, Mathadology, Analysis
and conclusion and recommendation.
this project is about A Sketch Planning exercise to estimate demand for a
commuter bus service. all the details are attached.
City of Saint John Has been selected among the lists. its advisable to put me in
loop during the preparation of report, and not wait till the report is completed,
the data will be extracted from Statistics Canada, links and instructions are
provided how to do that, after getting the data, it needs to be imported into ARC
GIS MAP Software. expect affair amount of excel work to be done in
preparation to be imported in the GIS Map.
you must state any assumption you use in the report.
Length of the report is 1000 words excluding resources.
All GIS map and Excel calculation must be inserted in the report.
Student note:
for this project I selected Saint john, New Brunswick for this project
I have completed partial of the work which include part 2 in the requirement, I
have attached the ARC GIS Themaic Map so it can be attached along with the
report.
I have done some part - the first 2, which include the Median Age, Population
2021, 2016, and the pop change, Density as well
I also Gathered important information from Static canada
only part 2 is completed, 1, 3, and 4 are not completed and the report obviously,
so need to complete these
calculation for modal split is very important
this link I gathered from static Canada, just to ease the work(tutor must need to
check these links) : https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?
pid=9810050401&pickMembers%5B0%5D=1.3686&pickMembers
%5B1%5D=2.1
https://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2021/dp-pd/prof/details/
page.cfm?Lang=E&SearchText=saint
%20john&DGUIDlist=2021A00051301006,2021S0503310,2013A000413009
&GENDERlist=1&STATISTIClist=1,4&HEADERlist=49,51,50,48,52
https://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2021/dp-pd/prof/details/
Page.cfm?
Lang=E&SearchText=millidgeville&DGUIDlist=2021A00051301006,2013A0
00413009,2021A00051301006&GENDERlist=1&STATISTIClist=1,4&HEAD
ERlist=49,51,50,48,52,6
Travel Demand Forecasting: Parameters and Techniques this a supporting
documents that is required to preform the Modal Split, is also attached.
just look into the table of content, section Modal Split and you will find
everything you need to calculate modal split, such Coefficient, anything
required to preform the Unitility Function can be found there, such as
Coefficient andso on. I beileve its on page 53 (4.7 Mode Choice).
now for the travel time between the dessimnation areas can be done using
googole,
-
example has been attached – you can select any place inside the disimination
areas between the the the two, to calculate the Origion and Distination of one
Pair. and the copy of the Google map for all transit type must be included in the
report,
its either by appendics or in the body of the report if they will discus that
findings which they will
also part of the resources should be the supporting documents
any assumption is made must be documents very well in the report. /n Instructions
Need report in 1000 words excluding the resources
the format of the report is Introduction, Background, Mathadology, Analysis
and conclusion and recommendation.
this project is about A Sketch Planning exercise to estimate demand for a
commuter bus service. all the details are attached.
City of Saint John Has been selected among the lists. its advisable to put me in
loop during the preparation of report, and not wait till the report is completed,
the data will be extracted from Statistics Canada, links and instructions are
provided how to do that, after getting the data, it needs to be imported into ARC
GIS MAP Software. expect affair amount of excel work to be done in
preparation to be imported in the GIS Map.
you must state any assumption you use in the report.
Length of the report is 1000 words excluding resources.
All GIS map and Excel calculation must be inserted in the report.
Student note:
for this project I selected Saint john, New Brunswick for this project
I have completed partial of the work which include part 2 in the requirement, I
have attached the ARC GIS Themaic Map so it can be attached along with the
report.
I have done some part - the first 2, which include the Median Age, Population
2021, 2016, and the pop change, Density as well
I also Gathered important information from Static canada
only part 2 is completed, 1, 3, and 4 are not completed and the report obviously,
so need to complete these
calculation for modal split is very important
this link I gathered from static Canada, just to ease the work(tutor must need to
check these links) : https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?
pid=9810050401&pickMembers%5B0%5D=1.3686&pickMembers
%5B1%5D=2.1
https://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2021/dp-pd/prof/details/
page.cfm?Lang=E&SearchText=saint
%20john&DGUIDlist=2021A00051301006,2021S0503310,2013A000413009
&GENDERlist=1&STATISTIClist=1,4&HEADERlist=49,51,50,48,52
https://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2021/dp-pd/prof/details/
Page.cfm?
Lang=E&SearchText=millidgeville&DGUIDlist=2021A00051301006,2013A0
00413009,2021A00051301006&GENDERlist=1&STATISTIClist=1,4&HEAD
ERlist=49,51,50,48,52,6
Travel Demand Forecasting: Parameters and Techniques this a supporting
documents that is required to preform the Modal Split, is also attached.
just look into the table of content, section Modal Split and you will find
everything you need to calculate modal split, such Coefficient, anything
required to preform the Unitility Function can be found there, such as
Coefficient andso on. I beileve its on page 53 (4.7 Mode Choice).
now for the travel time between the dessimnation areas can be done using
googole,
-
example has been attached – you can select any place inside the disimination
areas between the the the two, to calculate the Origion and Distination of one
Pair. and the copy of the Google map for all transit type must be included in the
report,
its either by appendics or in the body of the report if they will discus that
findings which they will
also part of the resources should be the supporting documents
any assumption is made must be documents very well in the report.