2. Effects of Temporary and Permanent Technology Shocks in
a Deterministic RBC Model Version
(a) Figure 1 illustrates the impulse responses to a purely temporary
(i.e., with a first-order autoregressive parameter equal to 0) positive
12/12/2022 University of Reading EC302 2022/23 Exam Paper - Questions
2/10
technology shock (in quarter 1 -- see bottom-right panel in the
figure), of 1% (above the steady state) in a deterministic version of
the RBC model. What are the effects of this shock on the
endogenous variables in the model, namely, (log-)consumption (c,
top-left panel in the figure), the capital stock (K, top-right panel) and
hours of work (N, bottom-left panel)? (9 marks, 3 marks per each
of the 3 endogenous variables)
0.7948
0.7947
0.7946
0.7945
0.7944
0.7943
0.7942
0.7941
0.794
10.288
10.286
10.284
10.282
10.28
10.278
10.276
10.274
10.272
10.27
0.7939
10.268
0
50
100
150
200
250
50
100
150
200
250
0.3365
0.336
0.3355
0.335
0.3345
0.334
0.3335
0.333
0.3325
0.332
+
0.3315
50
100
150
200
0.01
0.009
0.008
0.007
0.006
0.005
0.004
0.003
0.002
0.001
0
50
100
150
200
250
Figure 1: Effects of a Purely Temporary (Impulse) Positive
Technology Shock of 1% (in Quarter 1) in a Deterministic Version
of the RBC Model
(b) Figure 2 illustrates the impulse responses to an anticipated (in
quarter 10 -- see bottom-right panel in the figure) permanent but not
persistent (again, with a first-order autoregressive parameter equal
to 0) positive technology shock of 1% (above the steady state) in a
deterministic version of the real business cycle (RBC) model. What
are the effects of this shock on the endogenous variables in the
model, namely, (log-)consumption (c, top-left panel in the figure),
the capital stock (K, top-right panel) and hours of work (N, bottom-
left panel)? (9 marks, 3 marks per each of the 3 endogenous
variables)
answers lab class 8 end lesson
12/12/2022 University of Reading EC302 2022/23 Exam Paper - Questions
0.808
0.806
0.804
0.802
0.8-
0.798-
0.796
0.794
0.792
8F
50
0.3345
0.334
0.3335-
0.333
0.3325
0.332
0.3315
0.331
0.3305
0.33
100
8-
N
150
√8
200
K
10.45
10.4
10.35
10.3
10.25
3/10
10.2
50
100
150
200
250
250
0.3295
50
100
150
200
250
0.01
0.009
0.008
0.007
0.006
0.005
0.004
0.003
0.002
0.001
50
100
150
200
250
Figure 2: Effects of an Anticipated Permanent Positive Technology
Shock of 1% (in Quarter 10) in a Deterministic Version of the RBC
Model
(c) List and briefly explain the key similarities and differences in the
panels of Figure 1 relative to the corresponding panels of Figure 2.
(7 marks, 3 marks per each for the 2 key differences and 1 mark for
the key similarity)
3. Effects of Monetary Expansion on Consumption and
Investment in Christiano et al. (2011): DSGE versus VAR IRFS
Figure 1 illustrates some of the key findings in Christiano, Trabandt
and Walentin's (2011) chapter in the Handbook of Monetary
Economics. Now we are not interested to check the "Hume-
Friedman observation" we emphasized in class, but rather to
compare what the impulse response functions (IRFS) simulated
from their estimated medium-scale DSGE versus corresponding
VAR models reproduced in the figure show with regard to the time
path of real consumption and real investment. In particular, indicate
in sufficient detail the similarities and differences between the
DSGE and VAR mean trajectories (marked by squares versus solid
line, respectively) and associated confidence intervals (marked by
dashed limits versus grey shaded area, respectively). Provide an
12/12/2022 University of Reading EC302 2022/23 Exam Paper – Questions
4/10
interpretation for the effects of monetary expansion, reflected in the
time path of the policy rate, the Federal funds rate (expressed in
annual percentage rate, APR, terms) in this US case (compare also
the relative magnitude of the effects in question).
352
Lawrence J. Christiano et al.
(25 marks)
Real GDP (%)
Inflation (GDP deflator, APR)
Federal funds rate (APR)
0.2
0.4
0.2
0
0.1
0.2
-0.2
ΟΙ
-0.4
0
-0.1
-0.6
-0.2
0
5
10
0
5
10
0
5
10
Real consumption (%)
Real investment (%)
Capacity utilization (%)
1
1
0.2
0.5
0.5
0.1
O
0
0
-0.5
-0.1
0
5
10
0
5
10
0
5
10
Rel. price of investment (%)
Hours worked per capita (%)
Real wage (%)
0.3
0.2
0.05
0.2
0.15
0
0.1
0.1
-0.05
0.05
0
-0.1
0
-0.1
-0.15
0
5
10
0
5
10
0
5
10
VAR 95%
VAR Mean Medium-sized DSGE model (mean, 95% probability interval)
Figure 10 Dynamic responses of variables to a monetary policy shock.
Figure 3: Impulse responses to an expansionary monetary policy
shock in the Christiano-Trabandt-Walentin (2011) medium-scale
NK model, % deviation from steady state
Christiano-Trabandt-Walentin (2011), Handbook of
Monetary Economics, Vol. 3A, Ch. 7, Fig. 10, p. 352.
Section B
Answer ONE question
4. Granger Causality Tests and Implied Ordering in a VAR
Table 1 provides results from pairwise Granger causality tests
based on the null hypothesis HO = noncausality performed on the
(quarterly) natural log-difference of Euro Area (EA) real unit labour
cost (diqEARULC), real GDP (dlqEAYER), price level (diqEAYED)
and narrow real money balances (diqEAM1R). The respective test
statistic probability value is reported.
12/12/2022 University of Reading EC302 2022/23 Exam Paper - Questions
5/10
For each of the four variables (i.e., for each of the four columns
containing probability values), state whether the test suggests which
variable Granger-causes another variable. Indicate these causality
findings by arrows, going from the variable which Granger-causes
the other variable. What possible ordering(s) would these Granger
causality test results suggest for estimating a VAR with these four
variables? Briefly justify your answer. (20 marks for each of the four
variables plus 20 marks for a well-justified final answer based on the
causality arrow diagrams)
any colums cause rows
Pairwise Granger Causality Test, p-values for HO=noncausality reported below
Dependent Variable in Regression (in 4 columns below)
DLQEARULC | DLQEAYER DLQEAYED DLQEAM1R
Regressor
(column below)
DLQEARULC
0.8540
0.0622
0.5909
DLQEAYER
0.0164
0.0003
0.2562
DLQEAYED
0.9437
0.1070
0.0010
DLQEAM1R
0.4593
0.0036
0.8204
Table 1: Granger Causality Test Results for 4 Variables for the
Euro Area, Quarterly Data, 1970:1-2010:4
Source: Our EA-US quarterly dataset used in the lab sessions.
12/12/2022